Featured Amenities

Location Details

East Setauket Self-Storage Amenities

Our East Setauket, New York location has a variety of self-storage units ranging from small 5’x 5’ units to extra-large 10’ x 40’ units. You can also rent a parking space so you never need to worry about where you’re going to park your trailer, RV or boat for the off-season. If you’re not sure which size you need, we are here to help you. 

Climate-Controlled Units

Sometimes it can go from balmy to frigid in a matter of hours in New York State, especially when the wind blows in off the water. It’s not fun for people and it’s also not fun for your possessions, so we ensure our self-storage climate-controlled units are kept between 78°F in the summer and 55°F in the winter. Because really, no one likes extremes!

Security Cameras

Everyone feels invisible from time to time, but you won’t ever have to worry about that here. We can see you, all the time (but not in a creepy way, just in a safety-first way). We have 24/7/365 security cameras so you can always feel seen when you visit us. We believe in keeping everyone safe and secure. 

24-Hour Access

Did you just remember your tire appointment is at 8am and the tires are in your storage unit? Are guests due in an hour and you forgot to grab great-aunt Tilly’s special soup tureen that needs to be on the table or the feast may not happen? Don’t panic, because you can access your unit any time of day or night, even on evenings, weekends or holidays. (Mind sharing the soup recipe?)

Motion-Activated Lighting

Anyone who has ever tried to sneak in after curfew knows how important good lighting is. We may not have a curfew, but we do have bright, motion-activated lighting that will come on in the hallways, entrances, elevators and other locations to help you see what you’re doing, and to help us see you! 

Digital Security System

If you want into the facility, you’re going to need your personal access code. No code, no entry. It’s one of the ways we keep you safe.

Convenient Drive-Up Units

It’s Sunday, the game is starting in an hour, and you have to pick up your lucky jersey from your storage unit. You can pull right up to your unit, open it, grab what you need and be on your way again in a snap. You can even keep the car running, although it’s not the most environmentally friendly thing to do, but you do you, boo!

Clean and Tidy

Nobody wants to find extra visitors in your unit you didn’t know about or invite, so we work hard to keep our facility clean. We also have a crew of exterminators that keep things pest-free.

Fenced and Gated 

Our East Setauket location is fenced and gated, and the gate only works with the digital access code. We have on-site parking as well, so you don’t need to worry about finding a parking spot on the road and lugging boxes in from the car. 

No-Contact Rental/Online Bill Pay

We are committed to convenient customer service, so you can review and pay your bill online. No more writing out a set of checks (does anyone still use checks?), you can review and pay your bill from the comfort of your couch, and you don’t need to change out of your dinosaur onesie to do it. 

Boxes, Packing and Moving Supplies

We have packing and moving supplies, including moving boxes, packing supplies, packing tape and bubble wrap (yay, bubble wrap!) to help you organize your move and your storage space. Come see us in the office and we’ll hook you up.

Dollies and Hand Carts

You can borrow a dolly or hand cart so you can move your possessions more easily to and from your storage unit. 

Protection Plans

Keep your possessions safe with $2,000 to $5,000 coverage starting at as little as $10 per month. Not sure if you need it? Check out Gain Peace of Mind with Storage Unit Insurance.

Month-to-Month Rentals

Are you at SUNY Stony Brook and need to store your college dorm decor for the summer? Did you have a flood and need to store things until repairs are finished?  We offer month-to-month, short- and long-term rentals.

Friendly, Knowledgeable Staff

Our staff can help you figure out how to reach our location, explain why there are so many right hand turns to get to our location, lend you a tape gun or set you up with your access code. They might even be able to explain the difference between Setauket and East Setauket and where one ends and the other begins, they are that good. They can also set you up with the right unit for your needs, and explain storage insurance options to you.

Getting to Our East Setauket, New York Location

Our East Setauket location used to be known as Island Storage. East Setauket is located in Suffolk County on the north shore of Long Island. If you’re coming from Stony Brook University, start out going southeast on Lake Dr. Turn right to stay on Lake Dr. then left onto Circle Rd. 

Turn right onto Shirley Kenny Dr., then left onto Nicolls Rd/County Highway-97. Turn right onto Lower Sheep Pasture Rd., then right to stay on Lower Sheep Pasture Rd. (remember to watch for sheep). Take a slight right onto Pond Path. Turn left onto Upper Sheep Pasture Rd. (look for sheep again). Turn right onto N Belle Mead Rd., turn right, turn left, and then turn right again. 

If you’re coming from Selden, Take Middle Country Rd/NY-25, then merge onto Nicolls Rd/County Highway-97 N toward Stony Brook. Turn right onto Mark Tree Rd., right onto Nesconset Highway/NY-347. Take the first left onto N Belle Mead Rd. Turn right, then right again. 

If you’re coming from Port Jefferson Station, head south on Patchogue Rd/NY-112 toward Chereb Lane. Turn right onto Nesconset Highway/NY-347. Cross Old Town Road. Hum the Lil Nas X/Billy Ray Cyrus song. Turn right onto N Belle Mead Rd. Turn right, then take the first right. 

Other Storage Post Locations Near East Setauket, New York

We have several locations for your convenience:

What’s it Like in East Setauket, New York?

Setauket and East Setauket are both hamlets within the town of Brookhaven in Suffolk County, although there is some debate about where one ends and the other begins, which is kind of like a conundrum wrapped in an enigma. What everyone can agree on is that it’s located on the north shore of Long Island. In 1777 during the Revolutionary War, a bunch of Patriots snuck up on British forces in Setauket Presbyterian Church, hid behind a boulder and started firing. Britain sent for reinforcements, and the Patriots left in a hurry. The church is gone but the boulder is still there. 

Both Setaukets, Stony Brook and the village of Old Field were historically known as the Three Villages, although clearly someone was a bit mathematically challenged since there are four villages, not three. In 1778, it was the base of operations for the Culper Spy Ring, founded by George Washington. Colonel Benjamin Tallmadge was tasked with obtaining information on British movements in New York City. He recruited both male and female spies, and the women used laundry drying on the line to send messages to the Patriots. The spy ring was instrumental in preventing an attack on Patriot ally Lieutenant-General Rochambeau just after his troops’ arrival from France. The ring also exposed Benedict Arnold and his traitorous ways.

Niche.com doesn’t separate Setauket/East Setauket from the town of Brookhaven, and gives the whole town high marks in family-friendliness, outdoor activities, health and fitness, diversity and nightlife. Seventy-nine percent of residents own their homes, and the median house value is $347,200. 

Why Storage Post?

Local Knowledge

We can recommend the Right Storage Unit for your Belongings, commiserate about how hard it is to determine where Setauket ends and East Setauket begins, tell you where to get the best coffee and explain the weird random directions to get to our location. Our staff is awesome, and they're here to help. 

Safety and Security

We have a fenced and gated facility, 24/7/365 surveillance, digital access codes and motion-activated security lighting. Your safety and the safety of your belongings is our number one priority.

Transparency and Convenience

We are confident we are giving you good value for your money, and we will tell you your total costs upfront, no hidden admin fees or sneaky surcharges. Plus, you can review and pay your bills online. 

Helpful Staff

Our staff understand the 5 Unique Storage Challenges of New York City, that you might just need storage for a couple of months and how to determine the right size unit for your needs. We can lend you the tape gun, give you more bubble wrap and explain how your personal access code works. 

Whether you need short- or long term self-storage, Storage Post offers you transparent costs, convenience access and a commitment to safety and security. Call us today at 631.210.6240 or stop in to say hi at our East Setauket location! 

Belle Terre Saint James Head of the Harbor Lake Grove Nesconset Port Jefferson Poquott Selden Setauket-East Setauket South Setauket Stongs Neck Stony Brook Terryville Terryville Road Historic District
11733 11776 11777 11790 11794

*Terms and Conditions Apply